The Handmaid's Tale actress recalled the sweet moment she shared with Jennifer Aniston at the 2020 SAG Awards back in January during her visit to Jimmy Kimmel Live. While reminiscing about the friendly embrace, Elisabeth joked that she was one of her pals and relived the time the media thought she attended Jen's star-studded 50th birthday bash last year. "I literally have never officially met her. We were staying at this hotel and my brother was dropping me off. I walked into the hotel and there were paparazzi outside, I was like who’s here and they said it was Jennifer Aniston's birthday party. And then, the next day, I had all these interviews asking me, like, ‘Oh, my God. You went to Jen's birthday party?'" Elisabeth continued. "And I decided to just, kind of, go with it. I wanted to be like, ‘Yeah, I did. We're really close.'" We've never met and I was like, ‘she’s going to think I'm such a weirdo.'"