Breaking All Barriers, Trump Is Back
- 16 Nov - 22 Nov, 2024
The ongoing political instability, frequent shutdowns of social media, the internet, and VPN access in Pakistan are having far-reaching consequences for the country’s economy, particularly in the tech, freelance, and IT sectors. Here are key issues that need to be identified and addressed.
Negative Effects on Economy
Government’s periodic shutdowns of social media, internet services, and VPN access are causing significant damage to various sectors of Pakistan's economy.
(1) Many businesses, especially those reliant on online operations, e-commerce, and digital marketing, experience significant losses during internet blackouts.
(2) Local businesses cannot reach customers online, while global businesses suffer delays and cancellations. In addition, disruption to financial services like online banking or mobile payment systems is also common. Political instability and unreliable access to digital platforms discourage both foreign and local investors.
(3) In the age of digital globalization, investors demand an environment that supports connectivity, free flow of information, and a stable digital infrastructure. The frequent internet shutdowns undermine this confidence.
(4) A significant portion of the workforce, especially in the urban centres, depends on digital tools for communication, collaboration, and work. Internet disruptions affect employees’ ability to do their jobs, leading to decreased productivity, missed deadlines, and ultimately, loss of business revenue.
(5) Educational institutions that rely on online platforms to teach and conduct exams also suffer when internet access is disrupted. This reduces the country’s human capital development potential, affecting future generations of skilled professionals.
Impact on Software Industry and Freelancers
Pakistan has one of the largest populations of freelance workers in the world, with a significant number working in the IT, software development, digital marketing, content writing, graphic design, and other online services sectors. These freelancers rely heavily on a stable and open internet to connect with global clients. The frequent shutdowns disrupt their work and income, leading to:
(1) Delayed Deliveries: Projects that require constant communication with international clients may be delayed or cancelled.
(2) Loss of Reputation: Freelancers and businesses in Pakistan could suffer damage to their reputation if they fail to deliver due to access issues.
(3) Income Loss: Many freelancers are dependent on international clients, and any disruption can mean a direct loss of income. Moreover, with the limited availability of payment gateways during such shutdowns, the ability to receive payments is also impacted.
Serious threats to the IT Industry
The software development and IT sector in Pakistan has grown rapidly, with the country serving as a major outsourcing hub for various international firms. However, the ongoing restrictions are putting this sector at risk by:
(1) Hindering Global Collaboration: Developers and IT professionals often collaborate on international projects using cloud platforms, communication tools (e.g., Slack, Zoom), and version control software (e.g., GitHub). Interruptions to the internet or VPNs disrupt this process.
(2) Decline in Client Acquisition: Many software companies and startups in Pakistan have potential clients overseas, and consistent disruptions to internet access affect their ability to acquire new business or maintain existing contracts.
Migration of Educated Youth and Skilled Workers
The ongoing political instability, lawlessness, and restrictions on media, including the internet, are contributing to an increasing number of educated and skilled youth considering emigration. Many young, educated professionals, especially those in fields like IT, engineering, and business, are seeking opportunities abroad due to the lack of job prospects, political instability, and the oppressive environment. Countries like Canada, Australia, the UAE, and the United Kingdom are popular destinations for skilled Pakistani workers. Entrepreneurs in Pakistan who rely on a digital-first business model (e.g., tech startups, online retail) may also look for environments with more political stability and less restrictive digital policies. The lack of digital freedom and consistent access to online platforms, as well as the constant risk of internet shutdowns, makes it challenging to grow tech startups in the country.
Political Instability Risks
If the political situation does not stabilize, it could exacerbate the migration of human capital, resulting in a significant loss of talent and resources. This would further cripple Pakistan's economic growth, especially in high-growth sectors like technology and services. Continuous internal instability and digital censorship may isolate Pakistan from the global community, limiting trade, investment, and collaboration opportunities. Over time, this could affect the country’s autonomy as it becomes increasingly dependent on foreign aid and remittances. With a growing exodus of educated youth and professionals, Pakistan risks facing a future where its economy becomes stagnant, with a significant brain drain leaving a gap in leadership, innovation, and skill labour. Pakistan's IT and freelance sectors are a major source of foreign exchange, with the country earning millions of dollars annually from these industries. Pakistan's freelancing community is one of the largest in the world, earning approximately 1.1 billion US dollars annually (as of 2023). In 2023, the IT and BPO (Business Process Outsourcing) sector was reported to have earned around 2.6 billion dollars from exports. This figure continues to grow. as more companies from Pakistan serve international markets, particularly in the US, Europe, and the Middle East.
The frequent shutdowns of social media, the internet, and VPNs, along with the ongoing political instability in Pakistan, are creating a volatile environment that hurts businesses, freelancers, and the economy as a whole. The software and freelancing sectors, which are important sources of foreign exchange for the country, are especially vulnerable.
Immediate measures to be take
The government should immediately stop the practice of shutting down the internet, social media platforms, and VPNs. This would restore the flow of information, business continuity, and public trust. If internet restrictions are deemed necessary for national security reasons, the government must ensure that such measures are temporary, transparent, and subject to judicial review. It must also be backed by clear legal frameworks that define the conditions under which restrictions are imposed and the duration of such measures. The government should allow the use of VPNs for business purposes, especially for sectors like IT and freelancing. Many professionals need VPNs to securely access global services and communicate with international clients. If the government deems certain foreign VPNs to be a security risk, it should work with local service providers to create secure, state-approved alternatives that guarantee privacy while allowing legitimate business activity.
Pakistan must adopt comprehensive data privacy laws that ensure both citizens’ and businesses’ data are protected from misuse, and that international businesses can have confidence in Pakistan's digital ecosystem. government should engage with IT industry leaders, digital rights advocates, and business communities to understand the real impact of shutdowns on Pakistan’s economy.
Pakistan should create a strategic framework for boosting digital exports, including simplifying the process of cross-border payments and ensuring reliable infrastructure for international transactions.
Pakistan should encourage free flow of information, including access to social media, to ensure that its economy can thrive in the global digital economy. Restrictions on media and digital tools must be limited to exceptional cases. Political instability and lawlessness are key drivers of economic uncertainty. The government must focus on improving governance, ensuring that laws are consistently applied, and making it easier for businesses and citizens to trust the system.
The solution to Pakistan’s digital economy crisis lies in creating a stable and open digital environment while addressing national security concerns in a way that does not harm economic growth. The government must balance the need for control with the demands of a modern, digital economy. These measures, while urgent in the short term, also require long-term planning and commitment to modernize governance, infrastructure, and education, ultimately ensuring that Pakistan remains an independent, prosperous nation in the digital age.
COMMENTS